What's an f/a ratio? And sure it'll still be tough but at least more plausible for players to actually compete in.
And an idea for how the ladder can work instead of players switching places: When a player wins a game with a player ranked above him, no matter how far above, he moves up a single rank. The player who loses goes down a single rank. If the higher rated player wins, he maintains his ladder position.
__________________
su -
|